Today is Pentecost in the Western Church, and also happens to be Mother’s Day in the U.S. I would suspect that in many evangelical churches, the latter is more celebrated (despite being a secular holiday). Even though I think in liturgical settings the Church calendar should take precedence over secular holidays, I have nothing against Mother’s Day, and will be celebrating it by taking my mother out.

That Pentecost and Mother’s Day fall on the same day this year got me thinking about how celebrating Pentecost is really celebrating a type of motherhood. After all, the birthday of the Church at Pentecost is the celebration of the founding of the Church, the body of Christ, and our symbolic mother. There is a long-held Christian tradition that the Church is our mother. St. Cyprian (3rd century) suggested that we cannot have God as our Father unless we have the Church as our mother. In other words, it is impossible to separate God from the community of believers that he established. The Catechism speaks to Church as mother too:

Salvation comes from God alone; but because we receive the life of faith through the Church, she is our mother: “We believe the Church as the mother of our new birth, and not in the Church as if she were the author of our salvation.” Because she is our mother, she is also our teacher in the faith (169).

The Church, “the pillar and bulwark of the truth”, faithfully guards “the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints”. She guards the memory of Christ’s words; it is she who from generation to generation hands on the apostles’ confession of faith. As a mother who teaches her children to speak and so to understand and communicate, the Church our Mother teaches us the language of faith in order to introduce us to the understanding and the life of faith (171).

Catholics also understand that Mary, the mother of our Lord, is a symbol of the Church as mother. The Catechism states it like this:

At once virgin and mother, Mary is the symbol and the most perfect realization of the Church: “the Church indeed. . . by receiving the word of God in faith becomes herself a mother. By preaching and Baptism she brings forth sons, who are conceived by the Holy Spirit and born of God, to a new and immortal life. She herself is a virgin, who keeps in its entirety and purity the faith she pledged to her spouse” (507).

As the mother of God, Mary is also our mother as well, which the Catechism addresses:

“Mary is “blessed among women” because she believed in the fulfillment of the Lord’s word. Abraham. because of his faith, became a blessing for all the nations of the earth. Mary, because of her faith, became the mother of believers, through whom all nations of the earth receive him who is God’s own blessing: Jesus, the “fruit of thy womb.”

Thus, Catholics have a rather full understanding of motherhood that includes, but goes beyond mere earthly motherhood. The Blessed Virgin Mary, and the Church (itself functioning in faith and humility as did the Virgin Mary), function as mothers to us. So this year, while certainly not forgetting your biological (or adopted) mothers, remember your spiritual mothers as well, the Church, and the Blessed Virgin Mary. Give thanks to the Church, the Blessed Virgin Mary, and your earthly mother, for their prayers, guidance, patience, and love!

I read a recent article about a priest who called for new strategies to keep young people in Church. I agree that this should be a vital aspect of parish ministry. Vibrant parishes usually have a lot for youth, a lot for older people, a lot for families, but outside of university campuses almost nothing for single or married younger people. As someone who is still barely a young adult, I want to unpack some of the arguments made by Fr. Cusick (who is quoted in the article).

1. Churches need better music, preaching, and hospitality- I don’t know what he means by this, but I would agree as long as I can define what constitutes “better!” If he means putting drums near the altar to play 1970s songs in 1990s style then most young adults would probably pass. Keep the liturgy traditional and dignified and save the hip and contemporary stuff for the coffee and conversation afterward.

2. Create “satellite” sites away from the parish for social activity and discussion- As long as he’s not talking about informal masses in someone’s garage, then I agree. Finding a place to connect, hang out, and build social relationships is important. In many ways, evangelicals understand that young adults typically don’t have families close by and need social contact through their communities. Catholic parishes outside of campuses would do well to understand this too and create opportunities for social connection and fellowship, like Theology on Tap.

3. We need a “new apologetics”- Once again, I agree, as long as he’s not talking about dumbing down. If he wants to teach the Catholic Faith to postmodern people in a clear way without compromising the Truth, then we here at Per Christum are way ahead.

Thoughts?

Jennifer and I are currently house-hunting, and have even made an offer on a home that is about 1/4 mile from school, meaning I could easily walk to work on nice days. We are finding that we have picked a good time to hunt for a house (because of the weak market and pretty low interest rates). We ask your prayers, and even friendly advice if you have it (I know that Chad recently bought a house).

Saint Joseph, Pray for us!

Image (not the house we are looking at…obviously!) from: wildcru.org/aboutus/tubney/tubneyintro.htm

6 Denominations in 6 Weeks

I’ve had an interest in Christian denominations since I knew they existed. I remember scanning Mead’s Handbook in High School, trying to decide where I would worship once I was on my own. This is an article I would have definitely related to 5 years ago and it’s a fun read even now.

If my religious experience were an ice cream truck, the only thing in the freezer would be vanilla pops. And, once every quarter, some grape juice.

and

Roman Catholic

At 8:55 a.m., the parking lot is almost full. I watch maybe two dozen people exit their cars and enter the building, but none of them are carrying a Bible. Huh. I leave mine in the car, too, because when in Rome …

. . .

Everyone does this routine—genuflect, cross, kneel, pray—before being seated. Me? I just plop down all Protestant-like. I might as well have been wearing a “Luther is my homeboy” T-shirt.

HT:  Ragamuffin

My dear brothers and sisters in Christ:

My brother’s mother in law died on Friday, May 2, 2008 (3 days ago) after 2.5 years of breast cancer which spread to her lungs, brain, and bones.

Her name was Delfina Rodriguez.

Into your hands, O Lord,
we humbly entrust our brothers and sisters.
In this life you embraced them with
your tender love;
deliver them now from every evil
and bid them enter eternal rest.

The old order has passed away;
welcome them into paradise,
where there will be no sorrow,
no weeping nor pain,
but fullness of peace and joy
with your Son and the Holy Spirit
for ever and ever.

Amen.

You think evangelicals memorize a ton of scripture?

Some do. But most, especially cradle evangelicals, have about 5-10 texts repeatedly reinforced throughout their lives. These they hide in their heart. These become their touchstones for their soteriology — their understanding of salvation. It’s somewhat like a child in a liturgical communion learning the Apostle’s Creed.

Now Catholics do this as well. Or at least we try.

But when I see “Verse for the Week” in my local non-denominational, evangelical service bulletin or missionary newsletter, I think, “why this one, and not another?”

It’s the Key Verse tradition.

crossposted at CINE

…because of high gas prices. Are Americans starting to think a little smarter?

Well, I guess doing something beats constantly complaining about high prices and doing nothing about it, which has seemed to be the trend among American drivers for too long. I like my 32 mpg car quite well, even if it doesn’t give me the “status” that a Hummer would give me, but I’d prefer the extra $$ in my pocket at the end of the month to any so-called status.

[Let it be known, that growing up and living now in a rural area, I know that some folks need big vehicles for agriculture and transportation.]

The United Methodist church recently upheld its current position, which is that “homosexual practice is incompatible with Christian teaching.” This was a part of a minority report that was adopted. The “majority report” (apparently not representing the majority of delegates) wanted to substitute the “incompatibility” language with “faithful, thoughtful people who have grappled with this issue deeply disagree with one another; yet all seek a faithful witness.” They also wanted to ask Methodists “to refrain from judgment regarding homosexual persons and practices as the Spirit leads us to a new insight” (emphasis mine). The delegates also voted to retain language preventing Methodist pastors from performing gay “marriages,” and rejected language suggesting “civil unions” were a human right. The UMC also affirmed the dignity of all persons, regardless of sexual orientation. As you can see from the photo above, not everybody was too happy with the current decisions.

So basically, Methodists have again rejected revisionist (and I use this not as a slur but for those who want to “revise” the discipline of the UMC) appeals for changes regarding appropriate Christian sexual morality. Of course, the progressives will not stop trying. They will continue to disobey the rules regarding sexuality, stressing “dialogue” and “living in tension,” and being “prophetic,” until that is, they “win the day,” and they can start literally enforcing the rules when conservatives break them! Maybe I am being cynical, but this is pretty much how it has happened in the Episcopal church, another mainline Protestant church dealing with sexuality.

However, the window to officially change the UMC in a more liberal direction may be closing. As is the case in most churches, the Methodist church is growing rapidly in conservative Africa, and declining in liberal conferences in the U.S. Apparently conservative conferences are growing in the U.S. Thus, the future of the UMC is likely going to be traditional, at least in terms of sexual morality. I grew up UMC, and have quite a few Methodist friends. In the West Ohio Conference, the bishop when I grew up was Judith Craig, who was extremely liberal, and from what I understand, was part of the Reimagining Conference (communion with milk and honey, prayers to Sophia, etc). However, the new bishop of the West Ohio Conference is known to be conservative, and many pastors from Asbury Theological Seminary (a conservative Methodist seminary in Kentucky) are in positions of power. Thus it seems like things are turning around for conservatives even in the U.S.

My dad is a UMC minister. I remember him telling me stories about UMC liberalism. The first ministry commission he went before refused to approve his ordination, because my dad insisted that belief in the bodily resurrection was non-negotiable. Oh, the heresy!! At any rate, it seems like the Methodists have stood firm. John Wesley would be proud.

UPDATE: Young progressives protest the conservative vote by initiating a 24-hour drumming circle next to the convention center, followed by a protest luncheon (no joke!). It’s my grad school all over again!

Image from www.umc.org

Dear all:

I would like to bring to your attention a great Catholic website dedicated to Catholic evangelical preaching. As a Chicago Catholic, I have become somewhat acquainted with local priest, Fr. Robert Barron, and his Word on Fire Catholic Ministries over the past few years. I’ve listened to his excellent talks/sermons on the internet and on the radio and I can only thank God for giving us such a good priest!

I would like all of you to please take a moment and visit his website. Among the things that you cannot miss looking into are:

• The Word on Fire Mission (Statement)
• The Catholicism Project (Catholicism will be a monumental, documentary series for high-definition TV and global release.)
• Word on Fire Audio Archives

Trust me on this one, you will not regret it!

P.S. Don’t forget to support this ministry with your prayers!

In July 2003, I was preparing to enter seminary to study for the Episcopal priesthood. That same summer, the Episcopal diocese of New Hampshire elected a man in an openly gay relationship, Gene Robinson, as bishop. I knew the sparks were going to fly at General Convention a few months later, since the convention had to approve the election. As a “closet conservative,” I was bothered by this, quietly mind you, for fear of getting kicked out of the postulancy process. I was baffled by the lack of concern about Robinson’s consecration at my local seminary, and in the wider Episcopal church. I eventually came to the conclusion that the Episcopal church really was Protestant, and willing to “go it alone” for the sake of its own view of “social justice” (heck, the word “Protestant” was in the official name of the Episcopal church up until a few years ago…that should have been a clue). So I decided to attend local American Anglican Council gatherings, banding together with a few other traditional-minded Episcopalians in the Southern Ohio area. I made quite a few friends during this time. However, in 2004, after concluding that the “Network” of conservative Anglicans was more talk than action, more process than result, I finally became open to the Catholic Church, and became Catholic in August of 2004. Almost five years later, it is interesting to see where everybody in our original group of orthodox Southern Ohio Episcopalians has ended up

[Note: this list is not meant to be comprehensive of all Southern Ohio conservative Episcopalians. However, this covers many of the people on a Southern Ohio AAC priests, seminarians, etc, email list I used to belong to, and includes those I knew at least somewhat personally. Those that I had never met or whose whereabouts I am unsure of, I didn't mention].

- One priest, Fr. David, the smartest of all of us, and a reader of this blog, is still an Episcopal priest in Southern Ohio faithfully doing God’s work under the radar. At Fr. David’s initiation, a few of us entered into some internet discussion with progressives in the diocese, to see if we could find some “common ground.” Sadly, this endeavor showed us that progressives and conservatives in the diocese truly were fundamentally opposed to one another on a variety of issues. Should we meet for someone Speedway coffee soon, Father?

- One of the group’s organizers left his local Episcopal parish in 2004, and now works with an Anglican group that meets (or at least used to) at a Reformed Episcopal parish. He still seems to be involved in the Southern Ohio American Anglican Council. Andy’s former parish, once pretty conservative, now goes out of its way to emphasize how “inclusive” it is, and how the congregation has transformed itself in the last few years to become more diverse (a buzzword-rich way of saying they don’t think homosexual sex is a sin anymore)…which is what happens I guess when a good chunk of conservatives leaves a parish.

- A former priest (and friend) of mine now pastors an Anglican parish (with the AMIA I think) a few blocks down from the old parish I once attended. I notice the former parish has declined in numbers quite a bit, down to about 20-30 on a given Sunday. I decided to become Catholic around the time this local church split. I believe Fr. Rick and his congregation are meeting in what is (was?) a Christian coffeehouse.

- Another friend, and former priest, at an Episcopal church in London, Ohio, became Catholic around the time I did, and his wife (also an Episcopal priest at the time) eventually joined him, obviously giving up any possibility of her being ordained in the Catholic Church. Rick is now studying for his PhD at a Catholic University. Interestingly, he started out pretty “progressive,” but after immersing himself in Scripture and the Church Fathers, came to a more traditional view of sexuality. Rick, Fr. David, Jonathan, and I were on the Theological Commission of the Southern Ohio American Anglican Council (it sounds more official than it was; it was mostly all of us getting together for some coffee and good discussion).

- Early in the controversy, a deacon in the Southern Ohio diocese left and joined the Vineyard. At this time I cannot recall her name.

- I am not sure what became of Deacon Will. Last I knew he was considering more evangelical options, if he ever decided to leave the Episcopal church.

- I haven’t heard from John for awhile. During his transitional diaconate he was functioning in the same parish that was sponsoring me for postulancy. He left the Episcopal church for Rome, I think just before I did, but I can’t recall exactly. He is currently studying for ordination under the pastoral provision. I asked my current bishop, Bishop Campbell about John a few months ago, and he responded, “he is still in the process.” I found a link to a letter John had written to his Episcopal parish right before he became Catholic.

- One priest, a lady with what is typically a man’s name, left the Episcopal church for what I believe was a Baptist or maybe even charismatic church.

- Fr. Ron, another member of our group, seems to be in the midst of some controversy right now. As he and his situation have been mentioned on Stand Firm, I don’t have a problem mentioning his parish. It is interesting right now, because Saint Matthew’s Anglican and Saint Matthew’s Episcopal both have websites, and both claim the same address. Apparently, the Episcopal loyalists get the Saint Matthew’s building back on June 1 (if a bulletin text from an Episcopal parish in Oxford, Ohio is right…I worked with the rector of this parish quite extensively, and even though I now oppose women’s ordination, I recognize the good work she is doing for the Lord). The Episcopal Diocese of Southern Ohio’s website lists Fr. Ron as “temporarily inhibited.” I figured Stand Firm or Kendall Harmon would be all over this, but apparently negotiations are happening under the radar.

- Jonathan and I became Catholic in August of 2004. We both now teach at Catholic high schools and operate various Catholic websites

Why did I write this post? The other day I was thinking back to those times, and how much I was struggling with my place in the Episcopal church, and within the Church in general. I didn’t struggle alone, but with friends and companions in the fight for orthodoxy. Nonetheless, I realized that over the last (soon-to-be) 5 years, most of us have left the Episcopal church, and many of us have left Anglicanism. It is kind of depressing in a way, but I know for a fact that many of our little group that have left are happy with the decision, and those who have stayed are joyful in their calling as well. It also shows just how many self-described orthodox in Southern Ohio have left the Episcopal church; If this is happening all over the country, TEC is most certainly moving even more leftward by default.

I often think maybe we should all get together for some coffee in London, Ohio, just for old time’s sake?? We’ll just have to make sure it isn’t Speedway coffee, for Fr. David’s sake, because Speedway coffee is rank heresy.

Today is the Solemnity of the Ascension, at least in many parts of the Catholic world. Some dioceses (including most in the U.S.) translate the feast to the following Sunday, and our Orthodox brothers and sisters on the Julian calendar celebrate it later in the year, since they just recently celebrated Easter.

The Ascension feast was highly symbolic to me when I began reading the Church Fathers and discovering the Church Year in college. Along with the Epiphany, the Feast of the Ascension was a thoroughly biblical holiday that I hadn’t celebrated as an evangelical Christian. It became a symbol to me of the incompleteness of the evangelical church year, which in my experience at the time (in college), generally consisted only of Christmas and Easter (as days, and not seasons). Growing up, I remember observing an expanded church year, celebrating Advent and (sometimes) Lent.

When I began researching the Ascension feast, I discovered that the Ascension was very important in early Christian theology, and it was regularly portrayed in art. In fact, the lion (Jesus) conquering the dragon (Satan) is a symbol of the ascension in early Christian artwork. As a part of the paschal mystery, along with the death and resurrection of Jesus, the Ascension constitutes an important part of the mystery of our salvation. This holiday gives us a chance to reflect on this important part of Christian theology.

I want to note that it was around the time I was discovering the Ascension feast that I encountered criticisms of the biblical ascension, e.g. claims that the Ascension was based on outdated science, which pictured the universe as three-tiered, Hades below, heaven above, and earth in between, literally. C.S. Lewis and others have addressed this concern, reminding us that whatever cosmology the biblical writers may have had, the Ascension event was supernatural, but had to be rendered in natural language. Thus, even if the biblical writers did conceive of Jesus going “up” to heaven (either based on what they observed, their cosmology, or both) this is not to say Jesus is still floating in space somewhere!

Image: “Ascension” by Giotto

I know it is a little late for an “earth day” post, but I wanted to point our readers to a nice Catholic resource related to the environment: The Catholic Conservation Center. The center has as its goal to “promote ecology, environmental justice, and the stewardship of Creation in light of sacred Scripture and living Tradition of the Roman Catholic Church.” Lest the word “environmental justice” raise a red flag, note that the site strives to be loyal to the Magisterium of the Church (and wants to be emailed if they aren’t). I think this is important, because some Christian conservation sites seem to be environmentalist first, and Christian last. One does not have to be a neo-pagan, pray to Gaia, or support PETA, to believe in the conservation and care of God’s creation.

I definitely support conservation and caring for the earth. I enjoy nature, and being out in it, and like many Church Fathers, I believe that we can know something about our Creator from His marvelous creation. I lament the destruction and exploitation of our world, although I believe it is our right to use the earth’s resources justly for our benefit.

When I was growing up, some in my evangelical church were suspicious of my enjoyment of nature; if someone enjoyed nature (or wanted to care for it), then he was deemed too close to paganism! However, when I became Catholic I entered an Incarnational church, a sacramental Church, where the physical is not divided from the “spiritual.” Fortunately, the Catholic Church has a solid understanding of the role of creation that is neither idolatrous nor semi-Gnostic.

Image taken by me, April 2008

Thank you, Cardinal Egan for standing up to the Truth, for being faithful to your God-given ministry as pastor and teacher of the Holy Catholic Church!!! Please do not stop! My prayers and those of thousands of people are with you. God bless you.

The Catholic Church clearly teaches that abortion is a grave offense against the will of God. Throughout my years as Archbishop of New York, I have repeated this teaching in sermons, articles, addresses, and interviews without hesitation or compromise of any kind. Thus it was that I had an understanding with Mr. Rudolph Giuliani, when I became Archbishop of New York and he was serving as Mayor of New York, that he was not to receive the Eucharist because of his well-known support of abortion. I deeply regret that Mr. Giuliani received the Eucharist during the Papal visit here in New York, and I will be seeking a meeting with him to insist that he abide by our understanding.

Mr. Rudolph Giuliani, are you aware of what Holy Scripture affirms about partaking in an unworthy manner?

Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of profaning the body and blood of the Lord. Let a man examine himself, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For any one who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment upon himself. (1 Corinthians 11: 27-29)

 Can PC help to keep an Iraqi Catholic Seminary open?

  click to enlarge

 Project Number: 11909
Project Title: Keep Babel Open
Description: Baghdad’s Babel College for Philosophy and Theology, which educates Iraq’s seminarians, has been forced to relocate to Arbil. Help keep its doors open.
Amount requested: $15,000.00
Contributions from donors: $4,244.10
Amount needed to complete the project: $10,755.90